There are some intriguing similarities, but also contrasts, between the current U.S. House of Representatives investigation of President Donald Trump and last year’s Missouri House investigation of Gov. Eric Greitens.
Both investigations began with committee hearings held behind closed doors.
Missouri’s House even adopted a rule that gagged committee members from talking about committee proceedings with others.
One reason for initially closing the hearings was that the woman subject to alleged misconduct by the governor sought anonymity. But another explanation echoed the arguments for closed congressional hearings – that an impeachment investigation is similar to grand jury proceedings held in secret to avoid subsequent witnesses adjusting testimony based on prior testimony.
In Missouri, the House committee ultimately held public hearings and released partially redacted transcripts of the earlier closed hearings. The U.S. House also plans public hearings.
Another similarity between Missouri and Congress involves avoiding the word “impeachment.”
Congressional Republicans regularly attacked the House leadership for using standing committees for the initial Trump investigation, rather than the House authorizing a formal impeachment process.
In Missouri, the House voted to authorize a special committee to “investigate allegations” against the governor. But House leaders rejected efforts to include the word impeachment as a possible committee recommendation.
Even when the Missouri legislature authorized a special session to continue the Greitens investigation, the petition used the phrase “disciplinary actions,” not “impeachment” as the purpose.
I was told that by avoiding the word “impeachment” in the nonimpeachment petition provided cover for some Republicans that maybe all they were endorsing in signing the petition was a potential reprimand, a kind of “the governor’s been naughty” resolution.
Another intriguing similarity involves soliciting foreign campaign support.
While that’s the core of the Trump investigation, the issue arose late in the Greitens investigation when a former campaign staffer testified Greitens discussed seeking foreign campaign contributions that would violate federal law.
The one huge difference between the two investigations involves the intense partisanship in the U.S. House.
Republican members of Congress regularly attacked the Democratic leadership. They even disrupted a planned committee session by storming the Capitol hearing room before the meeting.
In Missouri, there was no such partisan assault.
Although Missouri Democratic legislators disagreed with some aspects of the Republican leadership’s approach, it became a bipartisan collaborative investigation of the Republican governor’s behavior.
I hardly remember a harsh word uttered by a Democratic committee member against the Republican chair.
The ranking Democratic committee member, usually candid and blunt, obeyed the gag rule. She consistently turned aside my repeated efforts for information about committee issues, although clearly frustrated by the rule.
Of course, this bipartisan collaboration was facilitated by a Republican-controlled legislature investigating a Republican governor.
That’s similar to the 1994 impeachment of Democratic Secretary of State Judy Moriarty by a Democratic-controlled House.
Unlike the Trump and Greitens investigations, the word “impeachment” was not an issue.
Gov. Mel Carnahan called the legislature into a special session for the specific purpose of impeaching Moriarty – who, after House impeachment, was tossed out of office by the Missouri Supreme Court.
Moriarty had been convicted of having office staff back-date her son’s filing papers for the state legislature after the filing deadline. The conviction, which prompted the impeachment session, meant there was no need for secret committee testimony since there had been a public trial.
Unlike the U.S. president, whom the Justice Department has determined cannot be charged with a crime while in office, governors are not immune from prosecution. In fact, Greitens resigned in a deal to drop a criminal charge of stealing information from a nonprofit organization.
As for that first special session ever called by the legislature, it met only a few times.
Rules for the committee’s continued investigation were co-sponsored by the Republican committee chair and the ranking Democratic member – a sign of continued bipartisan collaboration so missing in Washington, D.C.
But with Greitens’ resignation, the special session adjourned after a joint session address by the new governor, Mike Parson.
Phill Brooks has been a statehouse reporter since 1970, making him the dean of the Missouri statehouse press corps. He is director of Missouri Digital News and an emeritus faculty member of the Missouri School of Journalism.
After changing its name at the start of the year to reflect expanded services, Loehr Health Center relocated; video gaming center Contender eSports Springfield LLC launched; and the 3-month-old Cowboy Boutique LLC rebranded as Prickly Cactus Coffee and Boutique LLC.
Tim Potthoff, project manager with Nabholz, says the construction industry needs skilled tradesmen. He says getting certified in a trade pays as well as most four year degrees without accruing as …
Paula Adams, president of Penmac, says they try to help clients find gainful employment regardless of whether they have a permanent address. She says they partner with Council of Churches to try …
“Sometimes I’m really bad at my email, other times, I’m very on top of it,” says Megan Short, executive director of Springfield Contractors Association. Short says to stay current, she often …
Donald Babb, former CEO and executive director of Citizens Memorial Hospital, says his grandfather was his first mentor. “He always told me, you can do whatever you want to do,” Babb says. “You …
Entrepreneur Amby Lewis says it’s important to show support for local businesses and events on social media. Lewis says liking. sharing and commenting on posts can increase awareness and help a …
Joe Hornickel, planning and zoning director for the city of Branson, says one of the community's goals is to have year round jobs like manufacturing. While Branson has good access to highways, …
Carrie Tennis, senior director of operations with Family Pharmacy, says focusing on communities, customers and culture is the formula for their success. Practicing kindness is a more than four decade …
Christina Ford, president and founder of The Rebound Foundation, says she used to constantly shift roles between work and home life. Another young mom told her she designated certain days to her …
Parks play a large role in our quality of life, from creating memories to generating more than $15 million in annual visitor spending. Diana Tyndall, marketing & sponsorship coordinator with the …
Chris Bryant, development and productivity coach with Murney Associates, says in real estate, you must take many factors into account to develop your business plan. Factoring in your work hour and …