While we have Mark Zuckerberg to thank for the social media website that provides constant contact with family members and friends, Facebook is in need of changes at the top.
It was clear after the Cambridge Analytica data breach scandal last year that something must be done, and investors haven’t forgotten.
In Facebook’s shareholder meeting last month, 68% of independent investors voted for a provision that would separate the board chairman and CEO roles, according to an analysis by Open MIC, an organization that works toward greater corporate accountability at media and technologies companies. The independent shareholders favored putting an independent board chairman in place, leaving Zuckerberg with the CEO title.
Additionally, according to Open MIC – or Open Media and Information Companies Initiative – 83% of independent shareholders voted to do away with a dual-class share structure that considerably favors Zuckerberg and other executives at Facebook.
Because of Zuckerberg’s alliances and his 58% control of the vote, predictably, the shareholder proposals got shot down.
Beyond the Cambridge Analytica breach that exposed the private information of 87 million users, shareholders also took issue with Facebook’s role, whether direct or not, in Russia’s influence on 2016 presidential U.S. elections, the proliferation of fake news, social media addiction issues and the ability for advertisers to discriminate by race when promoting marketing messages.
“We believe this lack of independent board chair and oversight has contributed to Facebook missing, or mishandling, a number of severe controversies, increasing risk exposure and costs to shareholders,” the proposal reads, noting in 2018’s annual shareholders meeting, 51% of independent shareholders favored separating the chairman and CEO jobs.
The Facebook board, also predictably, recommended shareholders vote against the provision prior to the vote, saying, “We do not believe that requiring the chair to be independent will provide appreciably better direction and performance, and instead could cause inefficiency in board and management function and relations.”
For their part, shareholders are worried about their investments, and they have the right to help direct policy at Facebook – especially when a majority speaks up.
They have cause for concern.
Following the release of the Cambridge Analytica breach in early 2018, Facebook still was able to hit a stock high of $218.62 on July 25 that year. However, that level hasn’t been achieved again; the stock hasn’t even crossed the $200 mark since. And while 2018 net income was up 39% for the company, 2019 started with a first-quarter profit drop of 51% to $2.4 billion.
Facebook also is facing a new round of government investigations over alleged antitrust violations. The House Judiciary Committee is probing the social media giant over allegations it uses its “extraordinary power over commerce, communication and information online” to gain an unfair competitive advantage, according to USA Today reporting.
“Unwarranted, concentrated economic power in the hands of a few is dangerous to democracy – especially when digital platforms control content,” House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, D-California, tweeted on June 3. “The era of self-regulation is over.”
The writing is on the wall here, and the paint’s beginning to drip.
At the least, Zuckerberg and team should consider leadership or share structure alternatives, rather than simply shutting down the investors who have supported the company.
It must be difficult for any company founder to relinquish power – even if it’s partial control.
But the investors have spoken. It’s time for a change at Facebook.
Springfield Business Journal Web Editor Geoff Pickle can be reached at email@example.com.
Drive-thru coffee shop Bigfoot Coffee Co. LLC opened; a pair of Springfield attorneys launched medical marijuana certification clinic The Med Card Co. LLC; and husband-and-wife owners Ryan and Lesley Day debuted their first business venture with the opening of The Farmhouse on Boone Cafe LLC.
Andrea Petersberg, owner of the Local Bevy, says the appeal of a local store holds a lot of value for people in and outside of Springfield. Petersburg says being a supporting part of the local connection for artists is important for her.
Randy Bacon, professional photographer and humanitarian, shares his story on how he left his job in the corporate world to pursue his dream. Now 60 years old and with signature character to his photography and business, he says he still is a 15-year-old boy with a camera.
Becky Thomas, co-owner of Third Street Sportswear, gives her advice for maintaining good relationships with clients. Drawing on her experience working with customers coast to coast, Thomas says equity and fairness are some of the best ways to build trust and respect.
Don Helms, co-owner of Munchie Moe’s, says it's important to know your business and to think ahead of your supply chain. Helms says COVID-19 has changed the way he has experienced business operation. He says foresight is key.
Janet Susdorf, business consultant and founder of Brain Power for Hire, LLC, discusses the importance of adapting and learning from failure. Drawing from the struggles she has faced in her own life as a sixtime cancer survivor, Susdorf talks about when to fight and when to accept change.
Jennifer Charleston, a 20-year veteran of the Springfield Police Department and the only female lieutenant in the department, talks with SBJ’s Christine Temple about her career in law enforcement and her new position in the department as a liaison to the LGBTQ+ community.
Moving from physical meetings to digital meetings can feel like a barrier, but Mackenzie Scherer, an independent technology business consultant, says it can be an opportunity. Scherer says that with good moderation, a digital meeting experience can make people feel more included in the discussion.
Abby Glenn, development director for Habitat for Humanity, says corporate partners are a huge asset to the work they do. Corporate donation matching programs help individual donors feel they are contributing more and help Habitat for Humanity cover the large costs of their projects.
Alex Neville-Verdugo, museum director at the Discovery Center in Springfield, describes the opportunities the Discovery Center has through partnerships with other educational organizations. Neville-Verdugo says the Discovery Center’s virtual learning program reaches across multiple countries, with traffic mostly coming from the U.S. and Canada.
Elizabeth Hurst, business development manager at HR Advantage, says we do see fewer women in the workforce today than before the pandemic. Hurst says many women want more flexible work environments and that is one way employers can capture the female labor force.