Queen City voters will consider four questions on the Nov. 3 general election ballot following a Springfield City Council vote last night.
Voters will be asked to decide on four sets of proposed revisions to the Springfield city charter, the city’s governance document, which cannot be revised without voter say-so.
Council bypassed the regular two-reading process for council bills by passing the election ordinance as an emergency measure. The ordinance explains that the deadline to get the questions on the November ballot is the tenth Tuesday prior to the election, which would be Aug. 25. There remains one regular council meeting, on Aug. 24, before that date.
The first proposed revision to the charter would authorize the city manager, currently David Cameron, to delegate authority to perform charter-assigned duties to a deputy. There are currently two deputy city managers: Maurice Jones and Collin Quigley. Additionally, approval of the question would allow directors of city departments to delegate authority for charter-assigned duties to “subordinate officers or employees within the department.”
It's a move aimed toward satisfying council’s priority of operational excellence, City Attorney Jordan Paul explained to council.
A charter review committee composed of city staff had this priority in mind as it looked at possible changes to operations in the governance document.
Paul said the charter does not contain delegation language, and there is no consistent rule about when delegation is permitted.
“This amendment would create a clear and consistent rule that if the power is assigned to the city manager, it must be performed by the manager’s office, but not necessarily by the manager personally, and similarly, if the power is assigned to a department director, it must be performed by the department but not necessarily the director personally,” Paul said. “What does not change is accountability for the decision, which remains with the city manager and department directors.”
Paul gave an example of special event liquor licenses, which must be approved personally by the city manager. This change would allow deputies to issue those approvals.
City resident Kevin Mueller raised a concern about how the proposed revision might dilute accountability.
“The city charter is not an employee handbook. It is not an internal policy manual. It is Springfield’s constitution,” Mueller said. “It establishes who has authority, who is accountable, what safeguards exist and which decisions ultimately belong to the people.”
Prior to the vote – unanimous among the eight council members present, with Craig Hosmer absent – Mueller urged council to exercise “much more scrutiny” before asking for voter approval, and he voiced an objection to the emergency measure.
Mueller compared the proposal to statewide Amendment 4, which failed by a five to one margin in the August primary election and which would have made it harder for citizens to propose and pass citizen-initiated amendments to the Missouri constitution.
“Whatever anyone’s individual reasons for voting no, those margins should get the attention of every governing body in the state,” he said. “Missourians overwhelmingly rejected major changes proposed by government that would have altered the balance of power and fundamentally changed how important decisions are made.”
Now, in Springfield, Mueller said, residents are being asked to consider charter amendments that raise questions of who holds power and who exercises oversights.
“I understand the argument for efficiency – I do,” Mueller said. “But there is a reason a charter assigns duties to specific offices when responsibility is clearly placed in one office, citizens know who is accountable, but when that authority can be delegated farther and farther down the organizational chart, accountability can become much harder to trace.”
Mueller questioned whether the city attorney had reviewed every charter-assigned duty that would become delegable and whether he determined if Missouri law requires any of them to remain with the official named in the charter. Mueller said voters should see the results of that legal review before the vote.
The second question approved by council would replace the current three-step merit rule adoption process with a two-step process, removing the city’s personnel board from the process and authorizing the human resources director to approve application forms in lieu of the personnel board.
The third question would authorize council to fully establish purchasing by ordinance and expressly designate the city manager as the default signatory for purchasing.
Paul said the charter’s framework offers at least two different procurement paths, creating ambiguity.
“This amendment would create one clear and consistent path for purchasing,” he said. “What would not change is the key policy underpinning this framework, which is the requirement for competitive purchasing.”
The fourth question would replace gendered pronouns in the charter with gender-neutral equivalents.
Wes Marr, elections coordinator with the Greene County Clerk’s office, said that the questions will go on the ballot as presented by the city if they are submitted by the Aug. 25 deadline.