Greene County Sheriff Jim Arnott tendered his resignation from county office today following his appointment by President Donald Trump to the role of U.S. marshal for western Missouri, for a term of four years.
Arnott’s nomination was confirmed by the U.S. Senate on Aug. 7 by a 51-47 vote, according to online Congressional records, with both of Missouri’s U.S. senators voting in favor of confirmation.
Arnott’s resignation takes effect at 4 p.m. today.
Arnott was elected to a four-year term – his fifth as sheriff – in 2024 but has chosen to leave the position early for the federal role.
Taking over as interim Greene County sheriff will be Sheriff’s Office Capt. Jason Johnson with an interim appointment running through Dec. 31 of this year. Voters will be asked to decide on a sheriff in the November general election, and Johnson is the sole candidate. The election will fill Arnott’s unexpired term, which runs through Dec. 31, 2028.
The sheriff’s salary is set at $134,266, according to the commission.
Arnott said in an interview today that he has been completing onboarding to his new role but has not yet begun the work.
Arnott’s resignation and the appointment of an interim replacement were the business of the Greene County Commission in a 9:30 a.m. meeting today. That meeting was disrupted by protesters opposing detention of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement prisoners in the Greene County Jail.
About a dozen members of the Immigrant Justice Collaborative protested outdoors at Cox Medical Tower, which houses the commission offices on the 10th floor, before the commission meeting, and they gathered in the meeting room and in overflow space during the proceedings.
As Johnson began remarks accepting his interim appointment, the group broke into a chant: “No ICE, no way, in the contract here today.”
Greene County Presiding Commissioner Bob Dixon ejected the protestors from the meeting and closed the door.
“You have no right to disrupt. You have a right to be here, but you don’t have a right to disrupt,” Dixon said.
In a written set of talking points, Miles Pearson, co-founder of the Immigrant Justice Collaborative, said the sheriff has spent $17 million in taxpayer dollars to detain and deport 5,000 people for ICE since the start of 2025, and fewer than 3% of detainees have charges listed on their arrest record. A third of jail space is being used to house ICE detainees, Pearson stated.
Springfield Business Journal reached out to the sheriff’s office for confirmation of these figures late this morning, but a response was not received by publication time.
Arnott, who has been with the sheriff’s office going on 38 years and was first elected sheriff by county voters in November 2008, said the transition will be a big one.
“Most people don’t do that – almost 40 years at the same job,” he said. “It’s most of my life. That’s what I know.”
He said he is excited about his new role.
Arnott said the sheriff is effectively a chief executive officer of the department and jail, and he added that he believes his administrative experience will serve him well.
“As a sheriff, an elected officer, you get your amount of money on Jan. 13, when the commissioners sign it – $66 million, here you go. I can spend that however I want,” he said. “You have to manage your checkbook, and we have come in under budget every year.”
Arnott said he ran his office as a business, with regular financial meetings and careful oversight.
“The sheriff runs the biggest restaurant in jail – 1,200 meals, three times a day. You run a small hospital; you have a medical unit, 32 RNs; you have doctors that you oversee. You have a mental health unit,” he said. “You have a really big laundry operation.”
There’s also the policing aspect – patrol, detectives, civil process, court security and more.
“Not everybody gets that, but yeah, the Greene County sheriff has to get that, because this is a massive operation,” Arnott said. “You do have people that assist you, but you have to lead it in the right direction, and it is totally the CEO of a pretty good-sized business.”
Johnson, who is in his 29th year with the department and has trained under Arnott, said he is not daunted.
Asked if he would operate in the model Arnott has established, Johnson said he does not anticipate drastic changes.
“There will be some changes, and I have a couple of key fundamentals that I’ll address when the time’s right,” Johnson said. “As far as ICE goes, that decision was made two years ago by Sheriff Arnott, and I’m going to continue honoring the valid ICE detainers and housing the ICE detainees as promised by our contract with federal authorities, so that’s going to continue.”
Johnson described his leadership style, saying he is someone who likes to get things done.
“I’m just kind of laid back until the time not to be laid back,” he said. “I’m just going to make sure that our men and women have the best tools and training to do their job to the best of their ability for the citizens of Greene County and provide excellent service for them.”
Johnson also said he is open to conversation, even with the Immigrant Justice Collaborative, though he said many conversations have taken place with the group in the past.
“If they have some new dialogue, obviously, we want to talk to them, but we’ve already answered the same questions over and over and over again,” Johnson said.
Johnson is scheduled to be sworn in by Greene County Clerk Shane Schoeller at 4 p.m. today.