A succession plan first discussed a decade ago was enacted April 1, as the second generation at Mid America Metals officially assumed the top leadership role.
The lengthy process at the Ozark-based architectural restoration company culminated with Brandon Donat named as CEO. He took over the role from his father and company co-founder Dale Donat, who had led since Mid America Metals started in 1985.
Dale Donat formed the company with his brothers Dean and Don, and he became sole owner in 2011. He moved to chairman of the board as part of this month’s leadership transition.
Donat said conversations with family members about a succession plan began in 2009.
“What I tried to present to them is that I could get hit by a bus and see what happens or I can plan for this event and make it as smooth of a transition with as little impact on the employees as possible,” he said. “That’s been my intent from the beginning.”
Donat said the plan also was brought up to employees on numerous occasions to keep them in the loop about the company’s direction.
Succession planning also started early at Carson-Mitchell Inc., said Jason Carson, who is CEO and co-owner of the Springfield-based construction company with cousin and President Chris Carson. Their grandfather, Chester Carson, and Larry Mitchell formed the company in 1946, and second-generation brothers Kit, Jim and Doug came on board in the late ’60s and early ’70s.
All eventually took on ownership positions, Jason Carson said, noting he and Chris are now sole owners of the company. The cousins were part of a succession plan executed in May 2018.
“It was certainly in the back of our minds,” Jason Carson said of eventually taking over the family business. “But you don’t know if you’re going to like doing what you’re doing. It takes a while to determine if you’re going to stick with it.”
The Carson cousins both started working full time for the family business in the early 2000s. Discussions to succeed the elder Carsons emerged organically, Jason Carson said.
Chris Carson’s father Kit died in February at the age of 75. He was chairman of the board at the time. Jim Carson, Jason’s father, and Doug Carson remain on the board of directors – roles they transitioned to last May.
Similar to the Carsons, Brandon Donat, 33, has had years of experience in his company. Most recently serving as president, Donat started with the company 14 years ago and now leads more than 100 employees in a dozen offices across eight states. Donat is based in a St. Louis office and plans to remain there.
“I’ll be going to Springfield once a month to show my face at the corporate level,” he said.
Dale Donat said most of the company employees already know his son.
“I’ve made him visible in the few years leading up to this, knowing that this time would probably come where he would become either the next owner and/or CEO of the business,” he said.
“So gradually it was getting the employees used to Brandon. There was a comfort factor with that.”
Mid America Metals refinishes architectural wood, stone, glass and metal surfaces. Donat said some of its recent clients include Toyota Motor North America Inc. for its headquarters in Plano, Texas, and UMB Bank’s headquarters in Kansas City. Its 2018 revenue was in excess of $10 million, with Donat noting the company has experienced annual revenue growth for 31 of its 34 years in operation.
The elder Donat’s responsibilities now cover acquisitions, overseeing the corporate office staff of 10 and working in strategic planning.
He’ll also assist his son as needed. Donat, 62, said he expects retirement is still several years away.
Not a straight path
Throughout the succession process, Donat said the path wasn’t straightforward.
“I thought I would just turn it over to him and we’d structure some kind of deal and get the loans and all that kind of stuff,” he said, adding various financial factors had to be considered. “In a financial liability, for instance, if he goes out and gets a loan to buy the business from me, I have to cosign for that. And I’m on the hook for many, many years.”
Donat said he went through that process with his brothers and didn’t want to again. Knowing a traditional loan wasn’t desired, the Donats explored other options, leading them in the summer of 2017 to hire Slate Partners LLC, a Denver-based boutique investment bank that provides advisory services for mergers and acquisitions. That led to a recapitalization process, which involves a corporate restructuring of a company’s debt and equity mixture to stabilize its capital position.
“It is somewhat of a lengthy process,” Donat said. “One thing I would tell people thinking of going down this process is whatever they put out there that it’s going to take, six months, nine months or whatever, you need to add a few months to that.”
Eventually, a management presentation to 15 potential buyers was organized and held over a three-week period in December 2017. Ultimately, Nashville-based Gen Cap America Inc. made an ownership investment in the company. Terms were not disclosed, but the family maintained full operation of the company upon the May 30, 2018, closing, according to past Springfield Business Journal reporting.
“I wanted to do not just what is right for me and the Donat family but for our 100 employees,” he said of his early goals. “I didn’t want anybody to lose their job. I didn’t want anybody to lose their pay or benefits or anything like that. I wanted things to pretty much go on the way they have for 34 years. Gen Cap presented that option and were clearly better than anybody else, in my opinion. That was a big factor.”
Words of wisdom
Succession planning is a conversation that can take a long time to work through, Donat said, and one that shouldn’t be ignored.
“What I would tell other business owners is you have to explain these things to your employees. They want to know what’s going on,” he said. “A lot of business owners and even employees don’t think about it. But, someday, the owner of the business has to retire.”
Jason Carson said the process should include leaving time for the next generation, or whoever is tabbed with taking over, to be able to learn management and leadership lessons.
“Start early in your planning process so you have time for the former leaders to groom the newer ones taking over,” he said. “That can be a long process to transfer all that knowledge.”
Bike enthusiast Cody Stringer is betting his bike share nonprofit will lead to a more bike-friendly city.
As employees are more mobile and have a desire to work from home, Haden Long owner of Ellecor, explains office spaces are trending towards a more home-like feel. Things like shared work spaces, office pets, and cozy furnishings allow employees to be selective about where they work and become more effective as a result.
Every industry has to navigate trend shifts, but Scott Shotts of Missouri Spirits describes the changes in beverage industry as anarchy. Tried-and-true spirits rules are being ignored. Learn how the local distillery balances following the trends for product development with taking risks.
Kevin Wyas, founder of ECRI, started his first business at the age of 19, ran the business for 16 years before selling it. He recognizes the benefits of starting a business so young when he had relatively little to lose. "The stress and the uncertainty of this would be crippling," he says for somebody accustomed to a regular paycheck.
ighty percent of questions are common across industries, so you don't need industry-specific experience to do effective market research according to Debra Kassarjian, independent consultant and owner of DKInsights. As a matter of fact, she thinks there is a great deal to be gained from exchanging ideas outside of your industry.
Danny Collins, 37 North founder and guide, says the biggest leap they took in the first year was to purchase a vehicle. That major financial investment, however, allowed them to provide their outdoor guide services at a price point they felt was more appropriate.
Springfield Diner owner Ömer Önder sits down with a restaurant consultant who starts challenging the menu offerings."No bashful food." The blunt conversation is the launching off point to determine how the Mediterranean influence will affect the young restaurant's offerings in the future. Made to Order is an ongoing sbjLive documentary series in collaboration with Springfield Business Journal tracking the rebranding of a local restaurant.
Haden Long, owner of Ellecor, opened a retail home decor business five years ago in a traditional retail space. When the interior design side of the business took off, she decided to renovate a 100-year old bungalow to better show off product samples and installations.
Scott Shotts, partner with Missouri Spirits, says when they started in 2011 there were approximately 300 distilleries in the U.S. and now there are more than 3,000 so competition has grown significantly. Diversification of their business model has helped them succeed.
Matthew Blystone of Theta Float Spa had the financial means to start the unique business, but used crowdsourcing for pre-orders to determine market interest in addition to gathering a nice cash reserve before opening.
Avery Parrish with the Springfield Regional Arts Council explains how businesses can display local art in their spaces for a fraction of the price of investing in a permanent collection. The corporate partnership program allows a business to select from a customized portfolio of local artists' work curated based on the company's mission and aesthetic that can be switched out every six or 12 months.