YOUR BUSINESS AUTHORITY

Springfield, MO

Log in Subscribe

Jury decides against developer Rita Baron in partner dispute

Posted online

Last edited 11:43 a.m., Aug. 25, 2026 [Editor’s note: This story has been updated with a clarification that not all claims and counterclaims described were forwarded to the jury, which considered only three claims from the plaintiff and three from the defendants. The clarification was at the request of plaintiff’s attorney Joe Passanise. The date of the final determination hearing – set after the original publication time – is also added.]

After four years in court, architecture firm owner and property developer Rita Baron has lost a lawsuit she brought against her former business partners in Four Corners Development LLC and Hamilton Builders LLC, developers Ryan Hamilton, Doug Hamilton and Michael Hamra.

At the culmination of a nine-day trial, a jury decided the case, which was complex. It ruled in favor of the defendants on six separate counts with a suggested award of nearly $1.3 million.

Baron filed an initial petition in July 2022, then filed a separate petition in January of this year. The second petition was then consolidated into the first case. The jury ultimately considered the consolidated petition, filed by Baron’s team on April 8 of this year and referred to as the second amended verified petition for equitable and statutory relief and damages in consolidated action. The defendants filed a counterclaim petition on April 11 of this year.

The four people involved in the case – plaintiff Baron and defendants the Hamiltons and Hamra – had partnered in Four Corners to develop affordable rental housing using state and federal low-income housing tax credits, as Baron’s initial petition explains. The four were also members of Hamilton Builders, which provided construction and development services for affordable housing projects. The members held equal shares in each of the two businesses.

Another entity, Trinity Housing Development LLC, was formed after Four Corners and included only the defendants without Baron. Trinity competed with Four Corners on development of affordable housing projects that are eligible for tax credits, the suit maintains.

All three entities – Four Corners, Hamilton Builders and Trinity – had shared office space, employees and overhead expenses. Baron’s initial complaint maintains that the Hamiltons and Hamra operated Trinity without prior approval of the other two businesses, without consultation with Baron and without Baron’s consent.

The lawsuit alleges that the Hamiltons and Hamra transferred funds from Four Corners to Trinity and to other entities without approval. The lawsuit also alleges similar transfers between Hamilton Builders and Trinity. It further alleges payment of distributions to the Hamiltons and Hamra without consultation with or approval by Baron and without comparable distributions to Baron.

A 2026 petition by Baron adds that the Hamiltons and Hamra started another company, Hamilton Builders Contracting LLC, at the same time they began Trinity, after Baron had expressed a decision to leave Four Corners and the original Hamilton Builders LLC entities.

Another defendant is introduced in Baron’s 2026 petition: Adam Horton, chief development and strategy officer for Trinity and former chief operating officer for Four Corners and Trinity. The complaint alleges that Horton created entities to serve as subcontractors on LIHTC projects without Baron’s knowledge.

The petition also alleges that Horton formed another company, Blue True Development LLC, to compete with Four Corners and to avoid a statutory cap on the number of allowable LIHTC projects for a single entity. The petition further alleges that the Hamiltons and possibly Hamra shared funds generated through the subcontracting companies and Blue Tree Development. Baron also maintains that the subcontracting entities submitted charges on Four Corners projects at a markup. The second amended petition, submitted by Baron in April 2026, goes into detail in describing the financial transactions that she believes benefitted the defendants, through distributions to themselves or through loans to the entities they owned, while leaving her out of the approval process and the distributions.

Defendants respond
In their counterclaim filed April 11, the defendants offer their own detailed account of the incidents Baron describes.

The defendants refer to themselves as “well-regarded and experienced developers with expertise in the field of affordable housing,” while claiming Baron is not a licensed architect. (Baron Design & Associates LLC appears as a licensed architectural corporation in Missouri Division of Professional Registration online records, while Baron is not among those listed with an architect’s license.)

The counterclaim states Baron founded Raga Properties LLC, a developer of commercial and residential properties, including affordable housing projects, and Raga began competing with Four Corners as early as 2019. The filing states that Baron told them of her intention to develop work in states that Four Corners was also targeting, but they countered that Four Corners should engage in those projects.

“Plaintiff refused and insisted on competing with Four Corners,” the counterclaim states, adding that Baron’s decision to compete with Four Corners had a negative impact on the latter company’s ability to generate enough revenue to continue to pay its employees and expenses.

The counterclaim also maintains that all four partners in Four Corners agreed that it would work on Missouri and Colorado projects without competition from member entities, but then Baron submitted an application for a Missouri LIHTC project through Raga, violating the agreement. Raga was awarded a Springfield LIHTC project in 2019, and the defendants maintain that they lost business opportunities as a result.

The counterclaim also states that Baron demanded Four Corners use her company, Baron Design & Associates LLC, for architectural work, but it claims that she was overcharging Four Corners by more than double.

The counterclaim also states that Baron violated her unconditional guarantee, something all members signed to ensure lien-free construction, by not contributing her share of funding by capital or loans as the agreement stipulated. Since 2020, the suit alleges, Baron refused to sign personal guarantees for Four Corners or Hamilton Builders, forcing the Hamiltons and Hamra to sign personal guarantees for bank loans without her.

“Because plaintiff would not sign personal guarantees, it made it difficult to get loans in the name of Four Corners or Hamilton Builders,” the counterclaim states. “But for defendants’ actions in funding Four Corners and Hamilton Builders, Four Corners and Hamilton Builders would have defaulted on its obligations.”

Jury verdict
The jury deliberated for two hours and 25 minutes on Aug. 14 on six claims, culled to include three by the plaintiff and three by the defendants. Not all allegations raised in the petition or counterclaim were forwarded to the jury.

According to the online court docket for the case, Baron dismissed her claim against the defendants for civil conspiracy on the final day of the trial, thereby dismissing claims that her opponents overcharged her during their business partnership, meaning those claims were not among the allegations forwarded to the jury for its consideration.

Hamilton Builders Contracting LLC dismissed its abuse of process claims against Baron on Aug. 13, according to online court records, the same day as that company, along with Four Corners Development LLC, dismissed their claims of unjust enrichment against Baron.

The court records show that on May 29, defendants Michael Hamra, along with Joseph Hamilton and John Hamilton, dismissed their claim for breach of fiduciary duty against Baron, thereby dismissing the allegation that Baron had overcharged her opponents for architect fees, meaning those claims were not among the allegations forwarded to the jury for its consideration.

Also on May 29, Trinity Housing Development LLC and Hamilton Builders Contracting LLC dismissed their unjust enrichment claim against Baron, according to the docket.

Four Corners and Hamilton Builders also dismissed their breach of fiduciary claim against Baron on May 29, according to the docket.

On Aug. 14, the jury ruled in favor of the defendants on all six claims submitted. They were as follows:

• Baron’s claim on behalf of Four Corners for breach of fiduciary duty against the Hamiltons and Hamra – jury found in favor of defendants

• Baron’s claim on behalf of Hamilton Builders for breach of fiduciary duty against Douglas Hamilton – jury found in favor of defendants

• Baron’s claim for fraudulent misrepresentation against Horton and Hamilton Builders Contracting – jury found in favor of defendants

• A claim by the Hamiltons and Hamra for breach of the operating agreement against Baron – jury found in favor of defendants and recommended award of $1.1 million to defendants

• A claim by the Hamiltons and Hamra for unjust enrichment against Baron – jury found in favor of defendants and recommended award of $1 to defendants

• A claim by the Hamiltons and Hamra for equitable contribution against Baron – jury found in favor of defendants and recommended award of $167,997 to defendants

The final determination and entry of the judgments will require a hearing before Associate Circuit Judge Nathan Taylor of Division 7 of the 31st Judicial Circuit Court. That hearing has been set for 1:30 p.m. Oct. 14.

A joint written statement from the four defendants was provided to Springfield Business Journal by their counsel, Ellen Bruntrager of St. Louis-based Blitz, Bardgett & Deutsch LC. In it, they said, “We appreciate the jury's careful attention throughout this lengthy case. They reached the right decision, finding in our favor on all counts. We are grateful for their service and their commitment to following the facts and the law.”

The defendants’ statement goes on to express a desire to move on from the issue.

“We are pleased with the outcome, ready to turn the page, and focused on what matters most: serving people in need of housing, supporting our employees and moving our business forward,” it says.

A brief statement on behalf of Baron by Kutak Rock LLP indicated Baron’s intent to take the case to the next level. It says, “We are disappointed with the results of the trial and will pursue all available options, including an appeal.”

Online court records show Baron was represented in court by Joseph Passanise of Wampler & Passanise PC.

Comments

No comments on this story |
Please log in to add your comment
Editors' Pick
From The Ground Up: Cheyenne Road multi-use trail with bridge

Complete with a 45-foot pedestrian bridge, this project adds a 10-foot-wide walking trail in front of Nixa’s High Pointe Elementary School and Summit Intermediate School.

Most Read
SBJ.net Poll
How often do you use artificial intelligence for your business?

*

View results

Update cookies preferences