At last night’s Springfield City Council meeting, more than 100 people showed up out of concern for a zoning change to a planned development in a rural corner of the city – one annexed earlier this year and still classified with a Greene County zoning designation of agricultural.
A development group listed as East Division Development LLC et al. has proposed a residential subdivision on the 48-acre site, generally located at 3830 E. Division St. in the northeast corner of the city, with a mix of single-family, two-family and multifamily uses. The development would have a total of 530 residential units.
Discussion of the proposal, however, never happened. Councilmember Abe McGull made a motion that was unanimously approved to remand the matter back to the city’s Planning & Zoning Commission.
McGull said the developer requested the remand to present new information to P&Z about the project. P&Z voted 6-2 on July 17 to reject the development, though city planning staff recommended approval.
“I have a pretty good feeling that it has to do with a lot of the comments and input that the citizens have about this project,” McGull said of the request to remand.
Residents' concerns, generally, centered on issues of density in the proposed development, as well as traffic, noise, lighting, drainage and accessibility for emergency services, according to minutes from the July 17 P&Z meeting on the matter.
Development group East Division Development was registered with the Missouri Secretary of State’s office in March 2024 by Gary R. Rauscher of Santa Cruz, California.
Neighborhood meeting notes by engineering firm Olsson Inc. identify the developer as Napredak Builders LLC, a company with offices in the John Q. Hammons Building, and Santa Cruz, California-based Canyon View Capital, whose website describes itself as a privately held corporation that manages and operates over $1 billion of multifamily real estate value in the nation’s heartland – including Stone Creek Falls on the edge of Republic.
McGull said his motion to send the matter back to P&Z was offered with a caveat for the developer: “I also have an expectation that he plans to meet with the neighborhood prior to going to the next P&Z meeting.”
Councilmember Craig Hosmer clarified with city staff that the developer does not have to have a public meeting, but the option exists. That’s a good opportunity to work out differences between the developer and the neighbors, he said.
He encouraged the developer to have a meeting at a location large enough to accommodate the number of people who would want to have some input.
“This does affect their neighborhood – it affects their property values – and I think it’s important that we give them an opportunity to have their say in front of the developer,” he said.
After the vote to remand the matter, council took a break to allow audience members to depart both the meeting room and an overflow area that had been opened to accommodate the crowd. Most of the room emptied out at that point.
Some of the concerns regarding the development were spelled out in the minutes of the P&Z meeting of July 17. Will Hoey of Olsson explained at that meeting that the intent is for a low-density development, creating a step-down from single family units to a villa-type middle model and then to four-story apartment complexes.
Jonathan Peitz, also an Olsson engineer, spoke at that meeting to note that there is an existing project to widen Division Street from U.S. Highway 65 to Eastgate Avenue and to install new traffic signals, and improvements at the intersection of Division Street and LeCompte Road would help with traffic concerns.
Ricky Haase of Olsson said the development includes amenities like pickleball courts, pools, play areas, basketball courts and walking trails, plus plans for some 3 acres of water detention on-site.
Resident objections centered on density. Keith Abercrombie said he was concerned that more than 530 residential units making up the planned development would be unsightly amid surrounding single-family neighborhoods. Bernie Burner worried that by allowing apartments in a single-family area, the development would open what he called “Pandora’s box.”
Kathie Christie, vice president of the Hickory Hills Property Owners Association, voiced concerns about high-density development forever altering the suburban country nature of the neighborhood, according to the P&Z report. She added that the development does not meet the needs for entry-level housing, while also voicing concerns about increased traffic.
Another resident, David Rosenbluth, voiced support for townhomes, duplexes or villas, but noted the four-story apartments in the planned development are concerning.
Other residents expressed concern about traffic, noise, lighting, drainage and accessibility for emergency services. They also pointed to a perceived failure of the planned development to conform with the city’s Forward SGF comprehensive plan, which designates the area as a traditional neighborhood intended for single-family homes.
The two P&Z commissioners supporting the development were Bruce Colony and Dan Scott.
Colony, who supported it with reservations, said it was the type of development envisioned in Forward SGF. He described it as diverse with “a little of everything sort of mixed in,” according to the meeting minutes.
“I know it’s tough for people to live in single-family neighborhoods to think about having apartment complexes move in … but I think that’s kind of where we’re headed on some of these bigger open areas,” he said.
He described himself as being on the fence about the project without more information about traffic impacts.
Scott was quoted in the meeting record as saying there was a lot of good potential with the project, and he proposed a motion to limit the building height to three stories. That would eliminate 74 units from a proposed 428, leaving 354 apartments. That amendment was approved.
According to minutes from the meeting, Commissioner Eric Pauly called the amendment a “Band-Aid solution” to neighbor concerns and said the proposal is close, but it’s not quite there.
Commissioner Chris Lebeck expressed objections on several grounds, saying, “Simply put, I think this is too big and too much for this area.”
Lebeck said the plan works against the Forward SGF goal of encouraging homeownership in the city’s neighborhoods, as well as its emphasis of creating quality places.
“This again cuts against the comprehensive plan because it is deteriorating a good place in the city of Springfield and its current form,” he said.
He added that the proposed development is incompatible with land uses in its immediate vicinity, as expressed by neighbors.
Lebeck said the most concerning part of the plan is the impact on vehicular and pedestrian traffic.
“It’s a traffic mess out there right now, and I have not heard a consistent answer of how this is going to be fixed before we put additional property owners or renters in this area,” he said. “This is an unanswered question, and until this question is effectively answered, I think it would be simply irresponsible to approve this in its current form.”
Commissioner Betty Ridge offered an additional objection: aesthetics.
“I’m very concerned about the aesthetics of our community,” she said. “That’s a beautiful area of town, and that’s a beautiful piece of property, and I just didn’t really want to see it jam-packed with all those different types of structures,” she said.