YOUR BUSINESS AUTHORITY

Springfield, MO

Log in Subscribe

A request for a review of city policies was filed with the city Aug. 6 regarding alleged code violations at 1522 N. Grant Ave.
KATELYN EGGER | SBJ
A request for a review of city policies was filed with the city Aug. 6 regarding alleged code violations at 1522 N. Grant Ave.

City’s building inspection procedures questioned in court filing

Posted online

The city of Springfield is the subject of a lawsuit that seeks a judicial review of procedures used by the city’s Building Development Services department.

The court filing asks for a review of BDS procedures for administrative hearings, notices to property owners and property searches.

The suit was filed Aug. 6 by RCT Realty LLC regarding a house located at 1522 N. Grant Ave. RCT Realty is owned and organized by Crista Hogan, who is the executive director of the Springfield Metropolitan Bar Association. The plaintiff is represented by attorney Bryan Fisher of Neale & Newman LLP.

The court filing states that BDS sent the plaintiff a letter of condition regarding its Grant Avenue property in May 2025, with a second letter – this one asserting violations of the dangerous, blighted and nuisance building code and the International Property Maintenance Code – in February 2026, directing corrections to be completed by the following month. An abatement order mailed on March 12 required the plaintiff to begin reconditioning, repairing or removing the conditions by April 26.

On April 30, the complaint states, the city mailed the plaintiff a failure notice and set a hearing for June 17. An order was issued by hearing officer Rodney Wurgler on July 7.

The complaint by the plaintiff outlines several problems with the process. First, the city’s order said an answer from the property owner was permissible but not required, but it did not provide a date by which an answer would have to be filed. Additionally, the complaint states that the city did not identify information regarding discovery of facts in the case.

“The order did not state what action was necessary to remedy any of the alleged nuisance conditions,” the filing states.

The plaintiff claims in the filing to have abated alleged nuisance conditions prior to the hearing but adds that no court has approved any policies or procedures for the city’s administrative hearing, in keeping with state law.

The request for a judicial review is based on two factors, the first being there is no dispute of facts but rather on the application of law to the facts, according to the complaint.

Additionally, it adds, “The findings of fact are in excess of statutory authority, unsupported by competent and substantial evidence, unauthorized by law, made upon unlawful procedure, arbitrary and capricious and an abuse of discretion.”

The complaint states that the city’s hearing process did not comply with requirements of state law, specifically Chapter 479 of the Revised Missouri Statutes, which requires the city to adopt policies and procedures for administrative hearings, “subject to the approval of the municipal or circuit court.” It notes that there is no municipal court in Missouri – just the municipal division of the circuit court – meaning that policies and procedures must have been approved by the Circuit Court of Greene County, where the current complaint is filed.

“Upon information and belief, no court has approved any policies or procedures for the administrative hearing conducted by the city,” the filing states, adding that a hearing unpermitted by Missouri law is an abuse of discretion by the hearing officer.

The filing maintains that the city’s notice did not clearly outline the procedure for the property owner to respond to its order letter.

“The deficiencies in the notice mean that plaintiff was not properly summoned to the administrative hearing,” the complaint states.

The complaint also states that there is no finding that the plaintiff failed to comply with the order of abatement, since the order simply required the property owner to begin addressing BDS-identified conditions.

“There is no finding that plaintiff failed to begin reconditioning, repairing or removing any alleged nuisance condition,” the complaint states, adding there was no requirement that all conditions be abated by any given date.

The court filing finally states that the evidence presented by the city was the result of an unlawful search of the subject property. The complaint states that the plaintiff never authorized the city to enter its property, and no search warrant was obtained for officials to do so.

“Evidence obtained from an unlawful search is not competent evidence,” the complaint states, adding that competent evidence does not support the city’s findings of fact, and no witness, testimony, exhibit or lawful inspection establishes condition violations.

The suit asks the court to reverse findings of fact of the hearing officer and assess to the city court costs and any further relief deemed necessary.

The case is assigned to Associate Circuit Judge Kirsten Poppen, who has issued a summons to the city to file a pleading within 30 days.

Springfield Business Journal reached out to city spokesperson Cora Scott and attorney Fisher this morning.

Scott said the city just received its summons today. She added that the city’s policy is not to comment on pending litigation.

No response was received from Fisher by the time of this story’s publication.

Comments

No comments on this story |
Please log in to add your comment
Editors' Pick
Annual downtown holiday events combine for Nov. 21 celebration

Organizers hope to bolster client traffic to center city businesses.

Most Read
SBJ.net Poll
How often do you use artificial intelligence for your business?

*

View results

Update cookies preferences