YOUR BUSINESS AUTHORITY

Springfield, MO

Log in Subscribe

Brewing Resilience: Coffee shops navigate ongoing high costs of business

Posted online

With a quarter-century of experience in the coffee industry, including 21 years owning and operating a retail venture in Mount Vernon, Darrell and Tracy Bradshaw say the current economic landscape is making the cost of doing business a challenge to maintain and forecast.

Those challenges include high inflation and sustained, elevated costs for raw beans, known in the industry as green coffee, said Tracy, who owns KeenBean Coffee Roasters LLC with her husband. The company has two shops open in Mount Vernon in addition to its roasting operation.

“The last five years have been the most difficult and the most hard to predict,” she said, noting the balance of staying profitable while remaining affordable is “truly a dance.”

“It is being very smart, watching our costs, truly watching our portion sizes,” she added. “We’ve kind of increased our training to make sure that that staff is doing the exact same thing.”

Over the course of its history, KeenBean has roasted its own coffee. Darrell said when they started over 20 years ago, green coffee was 75 cents per pound.

“Our average cost of green coffee now is between $5 and $5.30 a pound,” he said, noting you also have to factor for roast loss, which is the reduction of the mass of beans as they turn into roasted coffee. “Then you’ve got labor, you’ve got overhead and a crazy little thing called profit that you try to click in there somewhere to keep the lights on.”

Rising prices
Michelle Billionis, owner of The Coffee Ethic LLC in downtown Springfield, said her company sources its green coffee beans from a variety of countries, including Brazil, Guatemala and Nicaragua.

“Coffee prices have been very unpredictable this year,” she said via email. “They increased by as much as 40% at one point.”

Darrell estimated KeenBean’s coffee costs have increased 30%-40% over the past year.

Billionis said tariffs initially were the primary reason for the price increases, but extreme weather in major coffee-producing countries has also factored into the rise.

“Low supply led to increased prices,” she said. “Generally speaking, I’ve never seen this drastic of a spike in green coffee prices in the 19 years we’ve been in business.”

Consumers have also been feeling the pinch of higher coffee prices at the supermarket. The average price of a pound of roasted ground coffee at U.S. grocery stores hit $9.72 in April, which marked the highest level on record since 1980, when the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics began tracking the price. The price in June, the most recent BLS data, was $9.45. The price has been elevated above $9 since September 2025.

The price for 10 ounces of ground coffee begins around $6 at Springfield grocers such as Walmart and Hy-Vee, as of Aug. 5.

As of June, the current U.S. inflation rate is 3.5%, a 0.4% decrease from May, largely driven by a drop in energy prices, according to BLS data.

Both KeenBean and The Coffee Ethic have increased prices on some of their menu items, with the total varying according to the companies’ cost of goods. Tracy said they’ve raised food and drink prices around 7% – a decision she added customers have largely been understanding about.

“We’ve got great customers, and they get it,” she said. “They’re seeing prices go up at the grocery store, at the gas pump and everywhere else also.”

That’s not to say the decision has been an easy one, she said.

“We are in a small town, and a lot of our customers, they’re getting hit the same way that we’re getting hit,” she said. “So, we carry it ourselves as long as we can.”

Like KeenBean, Billionis said the balance between profitability and affordability for her customers is a delicate one. Menu options range $2.50-$12.50, according to the company website.

“We provide several affordable options on the menu,” Billionis said. “We achieve this by creating unique items using ingredients bought in bulk, which keeps our cost of goods low.”

Making a shift
While Vintage Paris LLC in Hollister has also experienced high green coffee costs, Matt Farmer said a higher cost of doing business wasn’t why he and his wife, Jessica, sold the venture in June to Greyson and Mary Smither. The complexity and needs of the business didn’t match the focus Farmer said he and his wife had to offer to it anymore, noting the couple had a shifting of family priorities that took them away from Vintage Paris more frequently.

Still, reflecting on the business he owned for 14 years, the last few years were a challenge to adjust to higher prices. He estimated green coffee prices were up around 100% over the last two years prior to the sale of the company.

“Brazil has had three frosts year over year over year, causing supply to be lower, and then the demand has not stopped,” he said. “Along with inflation and then tariffs, it’s just compounding problems on the coffee commodity side.”

Farmer said Vintage Paris, which roasts coffee for its own use and also sells it to other shops, changed its pricing with wholesale clients last year to a variable model. Clients pay what Vintage Paris pays for the green coffee, along with a markup based on coffee market prices at the time of purchase.

“We had to change our model because of how fast and volatile the coffee pricing was. Basically, if we set a price, the next month we would be eating our own margin,” he said of pricing before the 2025 decision. “Or another month, it would be us charging way more than we want to for our wholesale partners.”

As for how long coffee prices may remain elevated, Tracy said she’s uncertain. She’s not even sure that a steady drop will even be a good occurrence for the economy.

“I’ve been saying it’s unsustainable. Whatever bubble it is has to pop,” she said. “And I don’t know whether that’s going to be a good thing or a bad thing. When coffee prices go down, we might be in a world of hurt because it’s going to be a reflection of other stuff that’s going on that’s not good.”

Billionis said she’s hopeful customers understand her business always tries to balance high quality, affordability and sustainability in its decisions.

“We love our community and are fully aware of the economic hardships our community and beyond are facing,” she said. “We are also experiencing the economic impact as a business.”

Diversification has been important for KeenBean, Tracy said, noting the business sells branded retail merchandise, packaged coffee and food along with its variety of coffee drinks. Still, the challenges persist, she added.

“It’s hard to be in any business, but coffee’s a rough one,” she said. “We’re not a necessary purchase. We’re an extra.” 

Comments

No comments on this story |
Please log in to add your comment
Editors' Pick
Transportation officials discuss $471M Forward 44 initiative

Project work in Springfield corridor will continue into 2031.

Most Read
Update cookies preferences