Last edited 8:31 a.m., March 13, 2018
There are two Missouri historical precedents that state lawmakers might want to consider in dealing with the state’s first criminally indicted governor.
One was the only removal of a statewide elected official. The other was the only use of a constitutional process to replace a governor judged unable to discharge his duties.
The first precedent involved the impeachment of Secretary of State Judy Moriarty. She had been convicted of back-dating her son’s filing for a legislative race after he missed the deadline. Gov. Mel Carnahan called a special session of the legislature for her impeachment.
There are some major differences between Moriarty’s situation and the potential impeachment issues now facing the Missouri House of Representatives involving Gov. Eric Greitens’ felony indictment.
Unlike Greitens, Moriarty was convicted before the impeachment process began. Another major difference was that, in the House investigation of Moriarty, witness testimony was completely open to the public.
Not so with Greitens. The chairperson of the investigation committee said witness testimony will be behind closed doors, and House rules give the chair power to censor the subsequent witness transcripts.
There’s an understandable sensitivity. Greitens’ indictment involves a charge of invasion of privacy involving a sexual incident in which the victim has sought anonymity. But keeping evidence secret denies Missouri citizens a full understanding about a House process involving the potential removal of the governor.
Another difference between Moriarty’s impeachment and the House investigation of Greitens is that Moriarty’s action occurred while she was in office. Greitens’ action under legislative investigation occurred before he was governor.
The disability board
The other precedent in Missouri’s history involving replacement of a statewide elected official provides an alternative to the path the House is now taking.
That precedent was set after the suspected death of Carnahan in a plane crash during his campaign for the U.S. Senate.
It led the state’s disability board, established by the Missouri Constitution, to declare the lieutenant governor to be the acting governor based on the constitutional provision giving the board authority to transfer the governor’s powers if it concludes that the governor “is unable to discharge the powers and duties of his office.”
One day later, Carnahan’s remains were confirmed and acting Gov. Roger Wilson became the state’s governor for the remaining months of Carnahan’s term.
A disability board approach is not as far-fetched as it might seem.
The initial announcement from House leaders after Greitens’ indictment raised the question as to whether the governor could lead because of the criminal case.
“We will carefully examine the facts contained in the indictment and answer the question as to whether or not the governor can lead our state while a felony case moves forward,” the three top House leaders announced.
As quoted by the St. Louis Post-Dispatch, Sen. Majority Leader Mike Kehoe voiced similar thoughts: “The news … causes me to question whether the governor has the ability to effectively lead the state going forward.”
Three of those legislators who expressed concerns about Greitens’ ability to lead while under indictment are members of the disability board. If those three legislative leaders truly believe there is a leadership issue, they could call for a board meeting to at least discuss the issue.
They constitute a sizable block on the nine-member disability board composed of the legislature’s four top leaders and all of the statewide elected officials – except the governor.
Once declared unable to discharge his duties, the constitution allows the governor to resume his office by declaring he’s capable.
But there’s a four-day delay in resuming office to allow the disability board to kick the question to the Supreme Court as to whether the governor is capable to discharge the powers and duties of his office. Such a Supreme Court hearing and decision would not be much different than the “seven eminent jurists” the Supreme Court dictates the Senate to select to make the final decision on impeachment.
This disability board process based on inability to govern would avoid pursuing permanent removal for something that occurred before the governor took office and for an indictment before a conviction. It would avoid the House committee having to investigate the seamy details of a sex scandal since the issue for the disability board would be limited to the leadership consequences of a felony indictment.
And that would avoid the need for the House investigation committee to violate the spirit of the open meetings law with hearings held in secret.
But it also would be a significant expansion of a provision – drafted not too many years after President John Kennedy’s assassination – that most likely was envisioned for medical disabilities.
Phill Brooks is director of the Missouri School of Journalism’s State Government Reporting Program. He has been a statehouse reporter since 1970, making him the dean of the Missouri statehouse press corps, and he manages the multimedia website on state government news, MDN.org. Brooks can be reached at firstname.lastname@example.org.
C. Arch Bay Co. is growing its multifamily residential portfolio with a two-building, 16-unit complex across National Avenue from Mercy Hospital Springfield.
Want to work for a non-profit? Linda Saturno, Executive Director of Child Advocacy Center in Springfield says volunteering is a great way to get started. You can learn all about different non-profits …
Mark Holmes, President of Consultant Board, shares how his mentor helped him hone his skills at public speaking, leadership, teamwork, and communication and how he now uses that knowledge to teach …
Jay Ryan, bartender at The Hepburn, shows how he crafts a cocktail with some seasonal flavors. The Hepburn is a members-only club fashioned after a 1920s speakeasy, located under Dapper Barber …
Jason Gage, City Manager for the City of Springfield, outlines how Springfield is distinct from other communities, positioning the city well for a national reputation. This is sponsored …
Katie Baker, owner of The Gracious Plate, says the biggest challenge for a new business is making sure the money you have coming in covers your expenses. While renting a kitchen lessened expenses and …
Jay Guffey, CEO of Mercy Rehab Hospital in Springfield, says it’s critical to have a succession plan in place. Whether necessitated by health issues, transfers, or job promotions, your team members …
Mickey Moore, CEO of Tomo Drug Testing, says their biggest challenge is hiring the right people. “We probably had to hire more quickly than we would have preferred. We care an awful lot about our …
“I think it’s really important when you’re starting a business to create good quality relationships. You want to find someone who has experienced starting a business,” says Debra Horn, Senior …
“We started doing this long-distance. We were in Denver when we were first getting the project up and running,” says Jennifer Leonard, Head Brewer at Tie and Timber Beer Company. Leonard says …
“A good leader has to be able to listen before they can make change or make decisions,” says Jessica Kruse, Associate Circuit Judge, Division 3 in Christian County. Kruse says when she joins an …